"Simultaneous Opening of Jeongja-Homae Sil" vs "Phased Construction Due to Budgetary Constraints"
The Jeongja-Homae Sil Shinbundang Line extension project stirred controversy as the government planned to complete the first phase, the 11.9-kilometer Jeongja-Suji-Gwanggyo section, as a private sector proposal by 2014 to coincide with the completion of Gwanggyo New City, followed by the second phase, the 11.14-kilometer Gwanggyo-Homae Sil section, as a government-financed project by 2019, citing difficulties in financing.
However, Gyeonggi Province, Suwon City, regional lawmakers, and residents of western Suwon are opposing the phased construction plan, insisting on simultaneous groundbreaking by 2014. Despite the local governments' commitment to secure a total of 1.4012 trillion won—comprising 1.01 trillion won in metropolitan traffic improvement costs generated from the Gwanggyo New City and Homae Sil land development projects and 400 billion won from the relocation of the railway base—criticism is mounting against the central government for lacking commitment to push the project forward.
Against this backdrop, a public hearing on the simultaneous construction of the Shinbundang Line extension was held on the 21st at a small conference room in the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido, Seoul, organized by Rep. Jung Mi-kyung of the Grand National Party. The hearing drew approximately 200 residents from the western Suwon area, demonstrating keen interest.
The public hearing, the first held under the new administration, attracted considerable attention, but the government's stance on "phased construction" remained unchanged.

The government cited insufficient funding as the reason for phased construction. However, regarding financing, Gyeonggi Province has proposed an additional burden of 400 billion won aimed at comprehensive construction. There are also revenue streams from the 1.4 trillion-won-scale Gwanggyo land development, Homae Sil land development, and the railway base relocation. The claim of insufficient funding does not make sense.
The government says it will begin phase two construction in 2014, but land and raw material prices will continue to rise indefinitely. From the residents' perspective, this statement amounts to nothing more than saying the government has no intention of beginning construction on the Gwanggyo-Homae Sil section.

In 2006, the Budget Planning and Management Office commissioned the Korea Development Institute's Public Investment Management Center to conduct a viability study on private investment for the Shinbundang Line extension. The study concluded that private investment including the second phase construction section would have low project viability. However, this came after the Ministry of Construction and Transportation released a basic plan concluding that phased projects could proceed with sufficient funding totaling 2.5411 trillion won—comprising 951.2 billion won in metropolitan traffic improvement costs resulting from large-scale land development projects, 1.1924 trillion won in national funds, and 397.5 billion won in Gyeonggi Province funds.
This means that if government funding were sufficient, the project would be viable without private investment. Therefore, if the first phase were conducted with private investment to supplement insufficient government budgets and the second phase with government budgets, the task would be straightforward.

If the Jeongja-Homae Sil section were constructed comprehensively and completed by 2014, it could mitigate early traffic problems in the Suji District of Yongin and Gwanggyo New City, reducing social congestion costs. However, considering the scale of national fiscal support for railway investment, this cannot be considered a realistic alternative. This is because it would lead to substantial financial burdens on both the central and local governments, hindering smooth project implementation and potentially prolonging the project.

As of 2003, the national rail transport share was 27 percent, while Gyeonggi Province's was only 6 percent. In the future, we must establish a metropolitan railway network in the Seoul metropolitan area and build a rail-centered public transportation system. The Shinbundang Line extension will complete a metropolitan railway network connecting Suwon and Gangnam. Therefore, this is a necessary project.
However, there are priorities in the utilization of national finances. If budgetary allocations are inadequate, construction is prone to delays. Rather than simultaneous groundbreaking, budgets should be invested rationally to ensure the project proceeds as planned.

The annual railway budget is 3.6 trillion won, of which the metropolitan railway accounts for only 540 billion won annually. The future project costs for ongoing metropolitan railway projects amount to 11 trillion won. That translates to 20 years until completion. We will reconsider the ideas proposed today.
However, if we are to divide and execute limited budgets, would it not be more effective to complete existing projects quickly and move to the next phase? The new administration is making efforts to secure social infrastructure budgets, and I hope residents will understand.

The government's determination to construct a metropolitan railway from Jeongja to Homae Sil is firm. Since we will realize it in phases, I would appreciate it if residents would abandon suspicions that the second phase project on the Gwanggyo-Homae Sil section will not commence. Implementing projects quickly all at once is not necessarily the best approach.
Looking at the Suin Line construction project, which began in 1995 and has progressed only 20 percent to date, the government has concluded, after considering such realities and project promotion directions, that phased completion is the wisest course.

Western Suwon has extremely inadequate railway infrastructure connecting east and west. The Shinbundang Line extension is absolutely necessary for connection with Hwaseong as well. The rail transport share of traffic demand within Gyeonggi Province is not even 8 percent. Given the need for low-carbon, eco-friendly transportation, we urge the government to construct metropolitan railways in Gyeonggi Province as soon as possible.
Since the Shinbundang Line extension is a long-cherished project of Gyeonggi Province, the province will actively step forward on the financing issue. We will address the financial burden in connection with new city development and other projects.

The first phase, the Jeongja-Gwanggyo section, will proceed as a private investment project. With private capital being invested, there is room for flexibility in financing. The city is willing to bear 800 billion won from the Gwanggyo land development district and 1.5 billion to 2 billion won from the Homae Sil district.
Furthermore, simultaneous groundbreaking would achieve cost savings of over 200 billion won compared to phased implementation. By locating the vehicle maintenance depot in Homae Sil rather than in Gwanggyo District, more economical facility construction is possible.

Please note that President Lee Myung-bak pledged in December of last year that simultaneous groundbreaking of the Shinbundang Line would be a key campaign promise. Particularly, during the first public hearing, the Ministry of Construction and Transportation stated it would proceed with simultaneous groundbreaking if three matters were resolved: railway base construction, underground line routes, and the construction of additional stations. These are matters that can be resolved if there is sufficient funding and will.
Currently available project budgets amount to 1.4 trillion won, and the total anticipated cost of phase two construction is 916.7 billion won. This leaves 480 billion won from the secured budget. If 200 billion won of this were invested to construct an underground route from Hwaseo Station to Homae Sil, residents would be more than willing to accept the railway base.




Loading comments…