'Samsung Road' Preferential Treatment Controversy Again... "Samsung Should Bear Increased Costs"

● City Assumes All Compensation Costs, Project Delayed
The 'Samsung Road Expansion Project,' which sparked repeated preferential treatment controversies in administrative audits in 2007 and 2008, again came under criticism this year without fail.
Councilor Kang Jang-bong stated, "The Samsung Road Expansion Project budget has increased by 23.7 billion won from the original estimate," and noted, "Even now, the city has failed to secure project funds in time, resulting in slow compensation and delayed project implementation." Councilor Kang further pointed out, "As compensation costs increased and project funds grew, the city and province must bear this burden, making budget securing difficult," and argued, "Since this is a project to improve Samsung's business environment, Samsung should bear a certain portion of the costs."
The increased compensation burden on the city was foreseeable from the start. When the province, city, and Samsung Electronics signed a memorandum of understanding in 2007, compensation costs and construction costs were divided separately by section.
The 3.12-kilometer section from the Samsung Road intersection in Woncheon-dong at National Highway 42 to the Segyero in Taejang-dong was divided by construction sections: the province and city agreed to cover sections 1-2, which include dense general neighborhood commercial areas, while Samsung Electronics would support sections 3-5, which are Samsung-owned. Particularly, compensation for private land was undertaken by the province and city. Consequently, despite foreseeable initial compensation increases, the city has borne all the burden.
Therefore, Councilor Kang emphasized, "We must find ways for Samsung Electronics to bear the increased project costs."
Kim Chung-young, Director of Construction and Transportation, stated, "We requested 20 billion won from the province this year, but only 10 billion won was provided due to financial constraints, causing difficulties in project fund procurement," and said, "While it is not appropriate to demand Samsung bear the compensation burden, we will review the matter. We will make efforts to ensure smooth implementation by securing the 42.2 billion won in unfunded budget."

● Design Advisory Committee's Inadequate Function Causes Administrative Loss
It was argued that the Suwon City Design Advisory Committee is not properly performing its advisory function, resulting in administrative losses, and that it is necessary to reconsider its function and role.
Councilor Kim Ki-jeong raised this argument at the City Council Urban Construction Committee audit held on the 26th. Councilor Kim stated, "There are considerable design changes in various projects pursued by the city, including the Suwon Station bypass road project," and questioned, "Why are there so many design changes when construction is undertaken after going through design consultation?"
Councilor Kim particularly noted, "While design changes related to underground utilities are understandable, design changes such as creating median flower beds that are visibly apparent should be avoided," and criticized, "Since design changes increase construction periods and costs, these must be reduced."
As a representative example, he cited findings from the Board of Audit and Inspection. Councilor Kim stated, "Regarding the Samsung Road Expansion Project, the city issued design contracts to relocate agricultural water channels that should have been closed, which was detected by the Board of Audit and Inspection, resulting in a cost reduction of 1.395 billion won," and asked, "If the Board of Audit and Inspection had not pointed this out, wouldn't this money have been wasted? Shouldn't design advisory committee members correct such irrational matters?"
In response, Director Kim Chung-young explained, "Design changes seem to occur because we try to do things properly in the implementation process," and stated, "Regarding the Samsung Road agricultural water channel issue, since work is divided among different departments, this situation occurred. Going forward, we will conduct design reviews with better site awareness."
Meanwhile, the city has conducted design consultations for projects exceeding 2 billion won, with 13 cases last year and 16 cases this year.
● KCC Site Development Must Address Traffic Issues First
Councilor Lee Jong-phil pressured the city to address traffic problems in the surrounding area and develop measures for single-family residential complexes within the district unit plan area in relation to developing the KCC site (Yeokseogwon 2 District Unit Plan Area) as commercial land. Councilor Lee stated, "If the chronic traffic problems in this area are not resolved, development will be practically difficult," and demanded, "Please provide solutions to eliminate this problem and present development directions for the single-family residential complex included in the district unit basic plan." Particularly, he noted, "This single-family residential complex will eventually be surrounded by commercial areas, which could lead to urban slum conditions and various civil complaints, so failing to present development directions even in the basic plan is problematic."
In response, Choi Jong-guk, Director of Urban Planning, who appeared as a witness, stated, "Currently, pre-impact assessments for traffic and environment are underway, and traffic issues will be discussed in the assessment results," and explained, "Also, some single-family residential areas within the commercial land will be classified as special design zones and will remain as general residential areas as before."
● Long-Term Unexecuted Urban Planning Facilities to Follow Principles
Criticism over compensation for long-term unexecuted urban planning facility sites also continued. Councilor Kang Jang-bong revealed, "Among long-term unexecuted facility sites, parks and road sites alone account for approximately 5.1 million square meters," and stated, "Upon careful examination, it appears that compensation is being delayed while pursuing large-scale budget-consuming projects not included in the original plan."
He provided evidence by citing the Samsung Road Expansion Project, which was not in the city's mid-term local finance plan, raising the budget from an initial 5 billion won to 10 billion won, and the Buk-Suwon IC road project with 35.3 billion won as examples of large-scale project budgeting. Councilor Kang argued, "If the city executed budgets only according to the mid-term local finance plan, there would be no difficulties in compensating for infringement of citizens' property rights or securing city finances."
In response, Choi Chul-gyu, Director of Urban Planning, stated, "The purchase costs for these unexecuted facility sites alone reach 300 billion won, and including project costs, it amounts to 3 trillion won," and explained, "Since this represents 20-30% of tax revenue, we will establish stage-by-stage implementation plans and proceed with compensation year by year."
● Strengthen Penalties for Large-Scale Retail Store Violations
Councilor Kim Ki-jeong raised the issue of 'safety negligence' at large department stores and discount marts in the Suwon area. Councilor Kim stated, "Despite the repeated pattern each year of large department stores and discount marts in Suwon stacking items near emergency exits or failing to properly secure evacuation routes while operating, not a single penalty was imposed over three years," and pointed out, "To increase improvement effects, disciplinary measures following crackdowns must be taken."
According to the 'Current Status of Illegal Activities in Buildings of Large Department Stores and Large-Scale Facility' data submitted by the city, the city conducted guidance inspections of large department stores and shopping centers in Suwon in the second half, detecting violations at 8 out of 14 locations. These businesses were caught stacking items in parking lots or evacuation routes, or illegally operating by installing sales counters and temporary tents in public spaces where business activities are prohibited.
Last year, 3 out of 14 locations were found in violation, and in 2007, as many as 9 locations had stacked items in parking lots, fire-safety zones, or evacuation routes, or installed temporary structures, and received the city's correction orders.
Councilor Kim stated, "Large retail stores' illegal activities that could lead to major accidents are being repeated annually, yet administrative correction measures alone are ineffective," and urged, "There is a need for continuous crackdowns and stronger disciplinary measures."
In response, Park Young-phil, Director of Urban Landscape, stated, "We will explore ways to link crackdowns and administrative measures, and ensure continuous on-site inspections are conducted."
● Why No Crackdowns on Enterprise-Type Street Vendors?
It was argued that Suwon City is not properly conducting crackdown activities on enterprise-type street vendors that substantially cause traffic inconvenience, while focusing on crackdowns on livelihood-type alley vendors, suggesting inappropriate crackdown priorities.
At the Urban Construction Committee's administrative audit of the Construction Division on the 26th, Councilor Kim Jin-gwan stated, "Annual contract costs for street vendor crackdowns amount to approximately 500 million won, yet the number of street vendors has not decreased at all," and criticized, "This is because crackdowns target only livelihood-type vendors operating in alleys, not enterprise-type vendors, merely accumulating crackdown records."
Councilor Kim further asked, "Why were organized enterprise-type vendors causing the greatest traffic inconvenience not cracked down?" and threatened, "At this rate, the contract budget should not be set at all, or if it has been, it should be cut."
Also, Councilor Kim Ki-jeong advised, "Street vendor crackdowns do not require special skills, yet contract workers' labor costs are classified as special labor, requiring more than general labor costs," and noted, "If the current labor cost is 180 million won, employing general laborers would cost only around 120 million won, allowing budget savings."
In response, Cho Yeol-ho, Director of the Construction Division, stated, "In reality, many street vendors operating in areas like train stations are operated by influential people," and said, "Going forward, we will improve the efficiency of street vendor crackdowns and develop methods for enterprise-type vendor crackdowns."
Meanwhile, the city contracted with six service providers including Wihun-yong Social Welfare Society Suwon Branch for approximately 1 billion won in budget this year, conducting 15,870 crackdown operations, completing on-site improvements in 14,779 cases, impounding 91 cases, and levying administrative fines in 63 cases totaling 3.14 million won.
● Provincial Route 1 Expansion 'Crawls Along'
Regarding the delay in the road expansion project for the 970-meter section from the Hwangbi Airfield Intersection in Gwonseon-dong, Gwonseon-gu to the Suwon City boundary in Daehwang-dong, Councilor Lee Jae-sik of the Urban Construction Committee shouted, "Over six years have passed since construction began, yet there is no sign of completion," and asked, "When on earth will this be completed?"
Road expansion construction began in 2005, but the completion date was postponed to 2010 due to budget shortfalls and compensation issues, causing conflicts with residents. Particularly, the project has been prolonged due to lack of proper inter-municipal coordination regarding the cost-sharing burden of bridge construction linked to the Hwaseong City section. Even if completed next year, expanding the 970-meter section at a rate of 161 meters per year represents a 'turtle's pace' construction.
Director Cho Yeol-ho stated, "Regarding the bridge, following consultation with Hwaseong City, it was verbally agreed that Hwaseong City would bear 55% and the city would conduct construction," and said, "Additionally, for the two locations where compensation agreements have not been reached, if land acquisition cannot proceed, we will resolve the matter through court consignment and expedite completion."




Loading comments…